The Binding of Isaac: Repentance+ AI Music Removed After Fan Backlash

Kuma
Kuma
November 22, 2026 at 3:08 AM · 4 min read
Clan MemberMajor General
Crying pale character surrounded by other cartoon characters

What Actually Shipped With Patch v1.9.7.19

The Binding of Isaac: Repentance AI music removed after fan backlash was confined to one secret daily run rather than the wider Repentance+ soundtrack, so context matters here. Repentance+ first arrived on Steam as a free DLC in November 2024, according to Power Up Gaming. The November 19, 2026 update brought Repentance+ to PS5, Xbox and Switch 2, with Nicalis' console launch announcement listing a $9.99 upgrade for existing Repentance owners.

The generated tracks were not part of the wider Repentance+ soundtrack. They belonged exclusively to a secret daily run unlocked with the seed V1CE BSMT, a Vice City homage complete with seven songs plus intros and outros. Nicalis deliberately timed the patch to land alongside GTA 6.

The break from tradition is what stung. According to The AI Musicpreneur, citing the Isaac wiki's music page, the music in Rebirth, Afterbirth, Afterbirth † and Repentance was made by Ridiculon, a credited partnership.

Suno Metadata, a Reddit Thread and a Very Fast Paper Trail

The discovery came fast. Reddit user ShweetsStuff flagged the tracks a day after launch, having extracted the files and found Suno metadata plus links pointing to Suno song pages. Other players confirmed the findings independently.

The timestamps made it worse. Metadata on one track dated its creation to October 30, 2026, less than three weeks before the update went live. This was not a long-gestating asset that slipped through; it was produced in the final stretch of a major console launch.

Precision about the scope varies by account. Dexerto describes "several tracks" carrying Suno metadata, while IGN characterized it as "a handful." GoNintendo went further, describing it as all of the run's original songs. The conservative, directly evidenced framing is several tracks with metadata linking to Suno pages, and the community-run Isaac wiki has documented exactly that, adding a note flagging the AI-generated tracks and recording the absence of any AI disclosure on the Steam page.

Steam Reviews Collapse to Single Digits

The reaction was not a mild grumble. Recent Steam reviews for Repentance+ collapsed to roughly 8 to 10 percent positive on November 21. Exact figures differ because the campaign was still escalating as each snapshot was taken: Dexerto put it at 10 percent of 908 reviews over the past 30 days, Power Up Gaming at 8 percent of 1,205, and The AI Musicpreneur at 8 percent of 1,081, explicitly noting the drop from the earlier 10 percent reading.

For contrast, lifetime English reviews sat at Mixed, with 52 percent of 3,048 positive. That gap between the historical record and the recent snapshot is the clearest measure of how hard the community turned.

AI music was not the only grievance. Players also reported crashes and mods broken by the update, and Nicalis later acknowledged fixing mod compatibility that had been "inadvertently broken." But the volume of anger tracked back to authorship. This is a community that has spent over a decade treating McMillen's personal credentials as part of the brand, a bond reinforced by the Ridiculon partnership, and The Binding of Isaac has rarely been bigger.

McMillen Says He Was Blindsided

McMillen's response on X was blunt. He said he woke up to "a shit show," that he "had no idea it featured generated music in the daily run," and that he was "looking into how that happened and getting it removed."

That statement reframes the entire story. The question is no longer whether AI music belongs in a game like this. It is who inside the pipeline put it there and how it cleared every checkpoint on the way to a console launch.

Nicalis' own patch note did little to fill the gap. It listed "Removal of generated music files," a Larynx + Car Battery bug fix, mod-compatibility repairs and console submissions, then added that the studio was "working on the game and will continue to address new and old bugs." No explanation of how the music got in. No explanation of why.

The disclosure problem is separate and arguably more serious. Valve's Steamworks content survey requires developers to declare "pre-generated" AI content shipped with a game, with sound explicitly listed among the categories. Repentance+'s store page carried no such disclosure.

The Modder in the Middle

According to Dexerto, the GTA run is credited to a modder known as Mr. Headcrab, who the original Reddit poster says is "staunchly anti-AI" and had no idea the music was generated. No one has publicly identified who created the Suno tracks.

That leaves his name attached to an official update containing assets he says he did not make, a credit problem distinct from the disclosure one. It is also one of the three questions still open, and the least likely to be resolved by a patch note.

PC Is Patched, Consoles Are Still Waiting

As it stands, the removal is confirmed on PC via the November 21 build. Console builds were submitted to Microsoft, Nintendo and Sony "ASAP," with no release date given. The music is not gone everywhere, and anyone claiming otherwise is ahead of the facts.

Nicalis has also said it is working with console first parties on discount parity for existing Repentance owners, addressing a separate complaint about the upgrade pricing.

The Win and the Gap

The community forced a removal in about two days, and that is a genuine achievement. Review bombing is a blunt instrument, but here it produced a fast, verifiable result: the files are out of the PC build.

What the patch note answered was "what." It never touched "who" or "why." A studio shipping a flagship console launch, on a date chosen to fight GTA 6, with undisclosed AI sound in a secret mode, and the creator of the game finding out on social media alongside his fans, describes a process failure that a file deletion does not repair.

Valve's rules require declaring AI-generated sound. This shipped without that declaration, and the removal solves the store page, not the pipeline that produced it. Until someone at Nicalis explains how Suno tracks reached a finished build, the fix is cleanup, not accountability.

Last updated: November 22, 2026 at 3:08 AM

Comments

0 Comments

Join the Conversation

Share your thoughts, ask questions, and connect with other community members.

No comments yet

Be the first to share your thoughts!